How to Become More Inclusive at Work: The Uncomfortable Truth About Why Most Diversity Training Fails

Connect with us: SB Nation | Medium | Eventbrite Community | Pexels | Quora

Three weeks ago, I watched a room full of middle managers sit through another mandatory diversity workshop, nodding politely while secretly checking their phones. The facilitator was lovely, the PowerPoint was colourful, and absolutely nothing changed. I've been running workplace training programs for seventeen years now, and I can tell you with brutal honesty: most inclusiveness initiatives are performative theatre designed to tick compliance boxes rather than create genuine change.

Here's what nobody wants to admit – becoming more inclusive at work isn't about sensitivity training or unconscious bias workshops. It's about fundamentally rewiring how we think about difference, and most organisations aren't prepared for that level of discomfort.

The Real Problem with Workplace Inclusiveness

Let me start with an uncomfortable truth: 78% of employees report feeling excluded at work despite their companies having diversity policies. That's not because HR departments aren't trying hard enough. It's because we're solving the wrong problem entirely.

Most businesses approach inclusiveness like they're painting over rust. They add policies, run workshops, and create committees without addressing the underlying culture that makes people feel unwelcome in the first place. It's like trying to fix a leaky roof by hanging prettier curtains – you might feel better about the décor, but you're still getting wet.

I've worked with mining companies in Perth, tech startups in Melbourne, and government departments in Canberra. The pattern is always the same. Leaders genuinely want inclusive workplaces, but they're terrified of having honest conversations about why their current approach isn't working.

What Inclusiveness Actually Means (Spoiler: It's Not What You Think)

Real workplace inclusiveness isn't about treating everyone the same. That's equality, and while equality is important, it's just the starting point. Inclusiveness means recognising that people bring different perspectives, experiences, and ways of working – and leveraging those differences as a competitive advantage.

Here's where I might lose some of you: true inclusiveness requires acknowledging that some traditional workplace norms are exclusionary by design. The expectation that everyone should communicate in the same direct, extroverted style? Excludes people from cultures where indirect communication shows respect. The assumption that networking happens over drinks after work? Excludes parents, people in recovery, and those from religious backgrounds where alcohol isn't appropriate.

I learned this the hard way about eight years ago when I was running communication training sessions for a large telecommunications company. I kept pushing participants to make more eye contact and speak up more confidently, completely oblivious to the fact that for some cultural backgrounds, direct eye contact with authority figures is disrespectful. One participant finally called me out on it, and I realised I'd been reinforcing exclusionary behaviour while teaching communication skills.

The Five Pillars of Genuine Workplace Inclusion

1. Psychological Safety (The Foundation Nobody Wants to Build)

Before anyone can be inclusive, they need to feel safe being themselves at work. This means creating an environment where people can disagree, make mistakes, and express different viewpoints without fear of retaliation or ridicule.

Most managers think they've created psychological safety because they have an open-door policy and say "we're all family here." But psychological safety isn't about being nice – it's about being honest. It means your team can tell you when your ideas are rubbish without worrying about their next performance review.

2. Curiosity Over Judgement

Here's something that might ruffle a few feathers: most workplace conflicts aren't about incompetence or bad attitudes. They're about different working styles clashing because nobody took the time to understand why someone approaches tasks differently.

I remember working with a team where the younger members thought their older colleagues were being obstructive by asking "too many questions" in meetings. Turns out, the experienced team members were used to working in an environment where asking clarifying questions prevented costly mistakes. The younger team members came from startup environments where rapid iteration was valued over detailed planning. Neither approach was wrong, but the lack of understanding was creating tension.

The solution wasn't sensitivity training – it was having honest conversations about different working styles and finding ways to combine the best of both approaches.

3. Flexible Communication Styles

This is where most diversity training programs fall short. They focus on what not to say instead of teaching people how to adapt their communication style to connect with different personality types and cultural backgrounds.

Effective inclusive communication isn't about walking on eggshells. It's about developing the skill to read your audience and adjust your approach accordingly. Some people need direct feedback delivered privately. Others prefer collaborative problem-solving in group settings. Some cultures value relationship-building before business discussions. Others see small talk as a waste of time.

The key is learning to recognise these preferences and adapting your style accordingly. It's not about being fake or losing your authenticity – it's about being intentionally flexible.

4. Systems Thinking About Barriers

Most inclusion efforts focus on changing individual behaviour, but real change happens when you examine your systems and processes. Who gets promoted? How are decisions made? What skills are valued and rewarded?

I worked with a professional services firm that couldn't understand why they struggled to retain talented women. Their promotion criteria heavily weighted business development activities like client entertainment and networking events that typically happened outside standard business hours. They weren't deliberately excluding anyone, but their system created barriers for people with caregiving responsibilities.

The solution wasn't quotas or special treatment. They redesigned their promotion criteria to include different types of business development activities and created more flexible networking opportunities. Suddenly, retention improved across all demographics because they'd created multiple pathways to success.

5. Accountability Without Shame

Here's the part that makes everyone uncomfortable: genuine inclusiveness requires calling out exclusionary behaviour when you see it. Not in an aggressive, confrontational way, but consistently and constructively.

Most people avoid these conversations because they're afraid of saying the wrong thing or creating conflict. But silence in the face of exclusionary behaviour is complicity. The goal isn't to shame people for making mistakes – it's to create a culture where everyone takes responsibility for maintaining an inclusive environment.

The Practical Stuff: What Actually Works

Enough theory. Let's talk about what you can actually do starting Monday morning.

Start with self-awareness. Before you can create an inclusive environment for others, you need to understand your own biases and communication preferences. I'm not talking about taking an online quiz – I mean honest reflection about who you naturally gravitate towards, whose ideas you're quick to dismiss, and what assumptions you make about competence based on appearance or communication style.

Change your meeting dynamics. Stop allowing the loudest voices to dominate every discussion. Use structured brainstorming techniques that give everyone a chance to contribute. Try starting meetings with silent idea generation before moving to group discussion. Rotate who leads different types of meetings.

Rethink your mentoring and development approaches. Traditional mentoring often perpetuates existing power structures because senior leaders tend to mentor people who remind them of themselves. Create reverse mentoring opportunities where younger or more diverse team members share their perspectives with senior leaders.

Question your "culture fit" criteria. Every time you find yourself thinking someone isn't a good "culture fit," dig deeper. Are they actually disruptive to team dynamics, or do they just approach problems differently than you're used to? Culture fit shouldn't mean everyone thinks and acts the same way.

The Hard Truth About Resistance

Let me be blunt about something that makes a lot of people uncomfortable: some team members will resist inclusive practices because they benefit from the current system. They might not even realise they're doing it, but they'll find reasons why new approaches won't work or why change isn't necessary.

This resistance isn't necessarily malicious, but it's real, and you need to address it directly. Have honest conversations about why inclusion matters for business results, not just because it's the right thing to do. Show how diverse perspectives lead to better problem-solving and innovation. Make it clear that inclusive behaviour is a performance expectation, not an optional nice-to-have.

Why Most Training Programs Miss the Mark

Here's something that might surprise you: most diversity and inclusion training actually reinforces stereotypes rather than breaking them down. When you spend two hours talking about different cultural communication styles, people walk away with a checklist of how "those people" behave instead of understanding that individual differences matter more than group membership.

Effective inclusion training focuses on developing skills – active listening, perspective-taking, flexible communication, and conflict resolution. It's less about learning about different groups and more about learning how to connect with individuals regardless of their background.

The best inclusion initiatives I've seen are integrated into existing business processes rather than treated as separate "diversity activities." When you embed inclusive practices into recruitment, performance management, project planning, and daily operations, they become normal business practice rather than special initiatives that people can ignore.

Making It Sustainable

Real change takes time, and you'll face setbacks. There will be incidents that test your commitment to inclusive practices. People will make mistakes, and some will question whether all this effort is worth it.

Here's what I've learned: sustainable inclusion isn't about perfection. It's about creating a culture where people feel comfortable addressing problems when they arise and learning from mistakes rather than hiding them.

You also need to celebrate small wins and recognise people who demonstrate inclusive leadership. Most recognition programs focus on individual achievement, but inclusion is a team sport. Start acknowledging people who amplify others' ideas, who create opportunities for different voices to be heard, and who handle difficult conversations with grace.

The companies that get this right don't treat inclusion as a project with a finish line. They treat it as an ongoing practice that requires constant attention and refinement, like maintaining a high-performance engine. It becomes part of how they do business, not something they do in addition to business.

Look, I'm not saying this is easy. Changing workplace culture is hard work that requires sustained effort and genuine commitment from leadership. But the alternative – maintaining the status quo while watching talented people leave because they don't feel valued – is far more costly in the long run.

The organisations that figure this out first will have a significant competitive advantage in attracting and retaining top talent. The ones that keep running ineffective workshops and hoping for different results? Well, they'll keep getting exactly what they've always gotten.